Lebanese Shiite Scholar Calls for Separation of Religion and State

The interview below was aired June 29, 2009 on Murr TV (Lebanon)

Atheist Media provided a transcript:

Muhammad Hassan Al-Amin: Lebanon is at a crossroads. Either it will opt for a modern civil state, or else it will move towards further disintegration and collapse, as long it adheres to such an extent to the sectarian regime.

Interviewer: How can we achieve such a civil state? You talked about a civil state, and about the need to move on from a political sectarian regime. Are you referring to the separation of religion and state?

Muhammad Hassan Al-Amin: Of course. The separation of religion and state goes without saying.

[...]

Religion and state are two different things. There cannot be such a thing as a religious state. A state is civil in essence, and therefore, a religious state is used by one group to facilitate [the establishment of] dictatorship and despotism. Religion must be separated from the state, and all the things that are presented as the absolute truth that Islam constitutes both religion and state have no foundation in Islamic thought or law. Islam is a religion. That's it. No more and no less. And the state is a state. A state is a man-made entity, which is chosen by the people and represents them, whereas religion is sacred. How can you incorporate the sacred into a worldly matter, about which people have different opinions?

[...]

A religious scholar who heads a political party is biased toward that party. When we have disagreements with him about this political party, we should be able to debate and disagree with him… With regard to political issues.

Interviewer: Yes.

Muhammad Hassan Al-Amin: I hope that none of these people are tempted to shield themselves with religion, just because they can, because it is easy to distinguish between religion and politics.

[...]

Nobody can claim that the concept of the Rule of the Jurisprudent is sacred, because it is not a religious tenet. Among the tenets of the Shiites, there is no such thing as the Rule of the Jurisprudent.

[...]

Any one of us whether a Muslim, a Christian, or even a non-believer is allowed to criticize the formula of [the Rule of the Jurisprudent], because it is a man-made formula, and not one of the tenets of Islam or of the Twelver Shia.

Courtesy of MEMRI TV

Sphere: Related Content

Related posts:

1. ACTION ALERT regarding Separation of Church and State
2. Separation of Church and State – What the Founders Meant
3. Separation of Church and State, Palin Style
4. Separation of Church and State – Milwaukee Area Graduation Ceremony in Limbo
5. Pat Robertson Calls Islam a Violent Political System
6. The Pope Arrives in Israel; Calls for Palestinian State
7. Separation of Church and State: Blasphemy Laws Still On the Books
8. Global Rebellion Religious Challenges to the Secular State from Christian Militias to al Qaeda Comparative Studies in Religion and Society
9. Whats God Got to Do with It? Robert Ingersoll on Free Thought – Honest Talk and the Separation of Church and State
10. Shiite Muslims Mark Ashura

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

Name (required)

Mail (will not be published) (required)

IMPORTANT NOTE: We welcome and encourage comments. However, we are receiving many 'junk comments' from people looking for back links. As of noon, November 16, 2009, comment submission authors must use a name. For example, names such as 'Payday Loans' or 'Home Accessories' will be deleted. You may continue to link to your website, but we want names (pen names are all right). Additionally, only substantive comments that have to do with the content of the article will be accepted. Comments such as 'Nice post, thanks,' will be deleted. Comments that link to pornographic or hate sites will also be deleted.

Website

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. While we offer immediate approval of comments that are not screened as spam, we reserve the right to delete your comment pursuant to the site's terms, conditions and policies.

Security Code: