Home / News / Idaho and Virginia in protest over legitimacy of Obama re-election
Idaho and Virginia in protest over legitimacy of Obama re-election

Idaho and Virginia in protest over legitimacy of Obama re-election

Two states are in the news today regarding the re-election of President Barack Obama. In Idaho, Republican State Senator Sheryl Nuxoll has chosen a discredited hypothesis that is popular on some of the Tea Party websites which states that if enough states refuse to participate in the Electoral College, Republican Governor Mitt Romney still has a chence to occupy the Oval Office, come this January.

In spite of winning fifty-one percent of the popular vote, Nuxoll still maintains that the legitimacy of Obama's re-election can still be challenged.

A report filed by ThinkProgress stated that Nuxoll linked to a website that still promotes the now-debunked idea of an Electoral College boycott, and was quoted as saying,

"…states are going to have to stand up for our individual rights and for our collective rights”

She further accused Obama of depriving citizens of their freedoms.

Emily Phelps, representing the 'Constitutional Accountability Center,' referred to a story on their website that outlines the details from an article which appeared on the conservative news outlet, 'World Net Daily,' where Judson Phillips, founder and CEO of the 'Tea Party Nation,' tries to justify why a quorum can be reached by the Electoral College.

From the CAC website,

By Phillips’ reasoning:

“Mitt Romney carried 24 states. We need to have conservative activists from all over the nation contact the electors, the Republican Party and the secretary of state in all of these states and tell them not to participate in the Electoral College when it meets on Dec. 17.

If we can get 17 of those states (just over one-third) to refuse to participate, the Electoral College will have no quorum. Then, as the Constitution directs, the election goes to the House of Representatives. That is how we can still pull this election out and make Mitt Romney president in January.”

The CAC responded with,

"There’s only one problem. The 12th Amendment doesn’t say that at all. Here’s the text itself:

The person having the greatest number of votes for President, shall be the President, if such number be a majority of the whole number of Electors appointed, and if no person have such majority, then…the House of Representatives shall choose immediately, by ballot, the President.

But in choosing the President, the votes shall be taken by states, the representation from each state having one vote; a quorum for this purpose shall consist of a member or members from two-thirds of the states…

A quick reading shows that Phillips has his voting bodies backward. There is no quorum requirement for the Electoral College."

World Net Daily is a right-wing site that focuses on conspiracy theories such as 'birtherism.'

In Virginia, Republican Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli told Brian Wilson and Cheri Jacobus of WMAL radio that he was in agreement that an investigation should be launched because Obama lost to Romney in all of the states that required a photo ID to vote, but still won re-election.

ThinkProgress reports that since taking office in 2010, Cuccinelli has lost lost most of the major legal cases he has brought to the court.

The story quotes part of the interview between Cucinelli and radio host Jacobus, which you can listen to here:



Cucinelli is planning to run for Governor of Virginia in 2013. For more information, details and statistics, you can read about the Idaho story here, and the Virginia story here.

About Al Stefanelli

Al is a retired author, writer and journalist. His books include "Free Thoughts - A Collection Of Essays By An American Atheist" and "A Voice Of Reason In An Unreasonable World - The Rise Of Atheism On Planet Earth." Al began writing in 1985, starting with the New York Times. In 1993 he joined a McClatchy newspaper, writing a weekly column for ten years. His writing continues to be widely distributed on the Internet and in print. He also produced and hosted a weekly syndicated radio broadcast from 1995 to 1998, and his work won a North Carolina Journalism award in 1998. Al is the former Georgia State Director for American Atheists, Inc., and served on the Board of Directors for "The Clergy Project." He is also a former Southern Baptist Pastor, having served two churches and as pulpit supply for three counties. Currently, he writes part time for The God Discussion, co-hosts the Internet radio programs, "The God Discussion Show" and "Reap Sow Radio." Al lives in the Atlanta suburb of Peachtree City, GA.
  • Deborah_B

    Can you imagine the outrage these folks would have if Gore had behaved the same way when he won the popular vote, but not the electoral college?

  • Spuddie

    Can we just have these people arrested for treason?

    After all they refuse to accept the authority of lawfully chosen leader of the nation.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=622450419 Tracy Walker

    Ken Cuccinelli's off in more than one respect. I don't know if it's an exception, but Obama carried Florida – and we have to show id to vote here.

  • Pingback: Virginia gubernatorial candidate Ken Cuccinelli's extremist views | God Discussion

Scroll To Top